Comments on: Liverpool 1 – 1 MAN CITY – PLAYER RATINGS http://www.viewfromablue.com/2011/11/28/liverpool-1-1-man-city-player-ratings/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=liverpool-1-1-man-city-player-ratings Tue, 20 Jan 2026 17:54:10 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.4 By: andy mccarthy http://www.viewfromablue.com/2011/11/28/liverpool-1-1-man-city-player-ratings/#comment-40594 andy mccarthy Tue, 29 Nov 2011 13:28:07 +0000 http://www.viewfromablue.com/?p=3976#comment-40594 Agree with marking on the whole and i too would have picked Nigel. However i would like to have seen Dzecko start as we get the best out of him when Clichy and Richards play as both put in early ball from wing. Sergio plays well of the big man also. Pity Reina not sent off as should have been and surprised at lack of comment on this. Agree with marking on the whole and i too would have picked Nigel. However i would like to have seen Dzecko start as we get the best out of him when Clichy and Richards play as both put in early ball from wing. Sergio plays well of the big man also.
Pity Reina not sent off as should have been and surprised at lack of comment on this.

]]> By: Goatman http://www.viewfromablue.com/2011/11/28/liverpool-1-1-man-city-player-ratings/#comment-40531 Goatman Tue, 29 Nov 2011 11:31:55 +0000 http://www.viewfromablue.com/?p=3976#comment-40531 I'm sorry, you are quite right, you didn't say deserved. I read that into it by mistake. I’m sorry, you are quite right, you didn’t say deserved. I read that into it by mistake.

]]> By: View From A Blue http://www.viewfromablue.com/2011/11/28/liverpool-1-1-man-city-player-ratings/#comment-40236 View From A Blue Tue, 29 Nov 2011 00:29:04 +0000 http://www.viewfromablue.com/?p=3976#comment-40236 I agree with everything you've said, though I stated it was a much-needed break, rather than deserved. I agree with everything you’ve said, though I stated it was a much-needed break, rather than deserved.

]]> By: Goatman http://www.viewfromablue.com/2011/11/28/liverpool-1-1-man-city-player-ratings/#comment-40186 Goatman Mon, 28 Nov 2011 22:24:03 +0000 http://www.viewfromablue.com/?p=3976#comment-40186 Totally agree, as I usually do, but not sure how you can say Yaya deserves a break, a huge kick up the rear end would be more appropriate for this idle shiftless overpaid player. With his talent and physique he should dominate every game from start to finish. Instead he ambles around as though he couldn't care less, rarely winning headers or tackles. He's shameful at times. Totally agree, as I usually do, but not sure how you can say Yaya deserves a break, a huge kick up the rear end would be more appropriate for this idle shiftless overpaid player. With his talent and physique he should dominate every game from start to finish. Instead he ambles around as though he couldn’t care less, rarely winning headers or tackles. He’s shameful at times.

]]> By: Alphie Izzett http://www.viewfromablue.com/2011/11/28/liverpool-1-1-man-city-player-ratings/#comment-40133 Alphie Izzett Mon, 28 Nov 2011 20:34:59 +0000 http://www.viewfromablue.com/?p=3976#comment-40133 There's always plenty of folk ready and willing to slag off Yaya! The guy has played far too many games in too short a space and he's lost his edge. I suppose the reasoning is that we'll lose him anyway for January so make hay whilst the sun shines, but for sure we'll miss him when he's not available. Hopefully Owen Hargreaves will be fit and stay fit by then, because he's the only player we have on the books able to play the sort of role that Yaya fills. Nigel De Jong, much as i love the guy, is a very different type of player and neither Milner nor Barry have that sort of presence and impact. Incidentally, Barry was worth at least as much as you gave James Milner, probably a tad more IMO. He's another unsung hero who has a queue of nob heads queuing up to diss him. There’s always plenty of folk ready and willing to slag off Yaya!

The guy has played far too many games in too short a space and he’s lost his edge. I suppose the reasoning is that we’ll lose him anyway for January so make hay whilst the sun shines, but for sure we’ll miss him when he’s not available.

Hopefully Owen Hargreaves will be fit and stay fit by then, because he’s the only player we have on the books able to play the sort of role that Yaya fills. Nigel De Jong, much as i love the guy, is a very different type of player and neither Milner nor Barry have that sort of presence and impact.

Incidentally, Barry was worth at least as much as you gave James Milner, probably a tad more IMO.
He’s another unsung hero who has a queue of nob heads queuing up to diss him.

]]>