Comments on: Newcastle 1 – 3 MAN CITY – PLAYER RATINGS http://www.viewfromablue.com/2010/12/27/newcastle-1-3-man-city-player-ratings/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=newcastle-1-3-man-city-player-ratings Tue, 20 Jan 2026 17:54:10 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.4 By: COLIN BELL IS MY HERO!! http://www.viewfromablue.com/2010/12/27/newcastle-1-3-man-city-player-ratings/#comment-615 COLIN BELL IS MY HERO!! Mon, 27 Dec 2010 18:03:03 +0000 http://viewfromablue.wordpress.com/?p=1297#comment-615 Have to disagree with a couple of things... 1.) Yaya was even worse than you say! 2.) Silva was slightly off the pace, wimped out of some hefty challenges and gave the ball away too easily, but i'll let you off because when I was wlaking with Charlotte we both saw him and he smiled at me! 3.) Barry should have been Man of the Match or Kompany. What a superbly taken goal by Barry. Kompany was in the way of everything, put his body on the line and made some splendid clearances. Would have given him a 9.5 4.) For all Milner's tenacity, he gave the ball away countless times, probably the most out of everyone bar Kolarov. He flew into some needless challenges too. He was here there and everywhere I do agree, but not MOTM worthy, especially when it was not him but Barry who pulled all the strings in the midfield. Would have given him an 8 5.) Tevez did a very good job upfront, took his first very nicely and he passed which was nice, and a great ball in by Milner. He did look injured though dont you think? Have to disagree with a couple of things…

1.) Yaya was even worse than you say!

2.) Silva was slightly off the pace, wimped out of some hefty challenges and gave the ball away too easily, but i’ll let you off because when I was wlaking with Charlotte we both saw him and he smiled at me!

3.) Barry should have been Man of the Match or Kompany. What a superbly taken goal by Barry. Kompany was in the way of everything, put his body on the line and made some splendid clearances. Would have given him a 9.5

4.) For all Milner’s tenacity, he gave the ball away countless times, probably the most out of everyone bar Kolarov. He flew into some needless challenges too. He was here there and everywhere I do agree, but not MOTM worthy, especially when it was not him but Barry who pulled all the strings in the midfield. Would have given him an 8

5.) Tevez did a very good job upfront, took his first very nicely and he passed which was nice, and a great ball in by Milner. He did look injured though dont you think?

]]>